FROM SOARS TO A STAR
Sillah Muhia Kinyanjui, 59 was arrested by flying squad unit on 15th September 1997 at Hannah’s Lodge, Pangani area in Nairobi County, where he was visiting his sister who worked in the hotel. His wife, father, mother, elder brother and a neighbor had earlier been arrested at their rural home at Kanunga / Ndakaine in Gatanga, Murang’a County. He had been arrested for allegedly killing his brother’s wife.
The entire administration of the surrounding area, including five police stations, was not aware of the alleged crime of the six suspects. He was whisked to Makuyu Police Station in the boot of the Peugeot 504 station wagon vehicle and tortured in the nearby forest the next day. He was suspended in the air by a rope tied to his wrists and treebranches, with the same rope affixing him to the trunk of the tree.
He was continuously battered at the knees and ankle joints by three policemen with what appeared to be wooden hoe handles, while the officer in charge ( a Mr. Kamunde - now deceased) kept watch with a cocked gun in readiness to shoot. His knee caps were totally crushed and the surrounding ligaments torn.
It was at the intervention of a herdsman, who was grazing animals nearby that the torture process was interrupted. The herdsman begged them not to kill him, at least not in his presence. After lowering him to the ground and in freeing him, they also tied a string to his testicles against a stone and asked him to jump whereby he sustained injury to his right hand side testicle. A blow with the hoe handle aimed at his right hand side jaw injured his forearm as he tried to shield the jaw so that his fingers could no longer stretch and one of them is still in that state. He lost five teeth in the process and a sixth one much later due to the impact of the blow.
He was thereafter taken to Thika Police Station awaiting charges at the Thika court. Upon arrival, the policeman on duty recognized him, being neighbors at home in Kanunga and alerted his relatives and friends about his extremely bad state. They came in large numbers and begged for medical intervention to be extended to him. With tight police escort, they were allowed to take him to a nearby private hospital, where his multiple injuries were attended to. At his first court appearance the judge ordered for his hospitalization on the 20th September 1997. He was taken to Kenyatta National Hospital where he stayed for the next three months undergoing treatment.
His case was referred to Nairobi High Court, when he refused to admit guilt and to acquiesce to their suggestion that he becomes a state witness. He was then remanded at the Industrial area Prison for the rest of his incarceration. It was while there that his injured jaw and gums flared up with serious inflammation. The doctor ordered for immediate treatment and replacement of teeth lost during the torture.
The whole process of incarceration in the remand prison system lasted for the next four years before he, his wife and his brother, the principle co-accused were acquitted 20th September 2001 for lack of evidence. His children at the time of arrest were at the delicate ages of 12, 10, 9, and 5 years and were left without a particular care giver due toabruptness of the arrest. They were deeply traumatized by this development and remain emotionally vulnerable. It was the community that came to their rescue and provided for their basic needs, including education in nearby schools.
The flying squad officers continued to harass the family even after his acquittal and would chase away anyone working in their small tea holding. The younger brother was in-charge of three butcheries owned by Mr. Kinyanjui and was also harassed so that the business closed down shortly after the arrest episode. As a trader in livestock, he used to travel to various market centers especially in Kinangop among others and this also was completely disrupted.
After the torture that Mr. Kinyanjui underwent in 1997, followed by four years of incarceration in remand prison, he sustained physical injuries to the knees, potency and psychological trauma without treatment. He came to IMLU on 23rd April 2015 and after a general assessment by an IMLU doctor and counsellor, they revealed that there was need to address Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, anxiety and profound loss while at the same time pursue medical support for sustained physical injuries and also legal support to seek compensation for violation of his rights.
According to his couzinselor, Mr. Kinyanjui has had a tremendous improvement despite the prolonged period of fourteen years without treatment for the effects of torture. “He can now squat in a pit latrine and support his weight at the knees much better than before following medical treatment. He used to be supported to stand-up under such circumstances.” Says Mr. Gitau. He also can take a walk to steeper terrain one kilometre away and return home without too much strain. Uncontrolled weeping when narrating about his ordeal to his listeners has dramatically reduced and is now able to state the facts without emotional triggers. Initially, he had lost his memory but can now slowly remember a lot.
He has two more therapy sessions to go and it is important to note that during his first four sessions, he was brought by his close friend 80-year old Johanna Chege from his home in Murang’a to IMLU offices in Niarobi. However, during the time of the interview, he was accompanied by his son.
He is grateful to IMLU for giving him a second chance in life by allowing him share his story with the rest of the world and help him get to his feet again so that he can continue providing for his family after fifteen years of physical, mental and financial challenges.
A history of the coup d’ etat in Black and White
The military camps in Eastleigh, Nanyuki and Embakasi were seized on the 31st July 1982, when the coup instigators were aware of the optimal timing and found it easy to take siege of these camps without any or minimal resistance. They then positioned themselves strategically to ambush and take control of all movements without any questions or queries. Anybody coming to the camps after the beginning of the coup were taken captive and used as decoys to wake up those airmen still sleeping in the billets. Then the Sirens went off, signifying external aggression to all those soldiers who were close by. Airmen then immediately dressed up to respond to the aggression, and to defend their beloved country. All airmen moved to the Armory, but little did they know that they were actually arming themselves without knowing that a coup had begun.
From the armory, the airmen were ushered into vehicles which took them to various points in the city centre to set up points of defense against what was thought then to be an external threat. Those who were away from the camps heard of what was happening on the Nairobi-based Voice of Kenya (VOK) Radio broadcast at 6:00 am the following morning and immediately returned to base. Thus, a coup was rolled out without all the airmen knowing what was happening, yet at gun point, they were forced to be part of a plot bigger than they could fathom.
General Mohammed, the then Kenya Army Commander and his selected group then went to VOK, surprising the unsuspecting airmen who had been left there without any instructions. General Mohammed was a well-respected Army General and he had the state power and force to decimate and destroy the coup, including those found at VOK and anyone suspected of being part of the coup attempt. The General ordered the airmen to be arrested and they were subsequently taken to Lang’ata Barracks where they were tortured mercilessly-not knowing exactly why they were being arrested. They were beaten with crude weapons, and left bleeding and traumatized by Kenya Army soldiers who believed that their comrades in the Air force had turned traitors. The airmen were then placed in the guard-room until evening when they were dispatched to Kamiti Maximum Security Prison in Nairobi.
In order to capture every airman, the army used the radio broadcast to pass the message, so those who were away from the camps were getting this information over the VOK radio, announcing the Coup. Not knowing which side of the divide to fall to, the airmen moved to the camps, only to be branded as rebels once they arrived. Then all airmen were rounded up, stripped naked and beaten, tortured and imprisoned without any proper legal process.
The whole country was in turmoil, as those calling themselves loyal forces started a very brutal exercise to decimate those wearing the blue Air force uniforms. Fortunately word went round very fast that there was a plot to wipe out all airmen, using the coup as an excuse. The airmen decided to remove all their uniforms and wear civilian clothing because nobody understood what was really going on.
Ambush centers were set all over Nairobi city to strike at the celebrating mobs without warning. Once shot at, if you survived, they would arrest you, strip you naked and torture you without taking the wounded for medical attention. That afternoon, the onslaught continued on all fronts including the camps, using even attack helicopters loaded with rockets to destroy as much as possible anywhere the airmen were thought to be.
Army brigades were then assigned to carry out assault on the three camps. At Eastleigh, on finding a near empty camp, they moved to the Sergeants’ mess and rounded up all who had gathered there under a white flag, stripping them naked and locking them up in a small office to the point of suffocation, finally ferrying them to Kamiti Maximum Prison naked. They then moved to the married quarters and robbed family members of all valuables and harassed those they found there.
The arrests were conducted in a very haphazard manner and many were shot and injured in the process. Those injured were never given medical attention and were instead arrested and beaten. The only hospital (Forces Memorial) specializing in treating soldiers with gunshot wounds, refused to treat the airmen and the airmen indicated that they were victims of torture while at the hospital. Many suffered in the hands of medical personnel, but all this was kept hidden by the regime.
The hospital decided to operate on some without anesthesia and removed seriously injured people from their care in hospital to the Prisons to be cared for by fellow inmates. Others were taken to Department of Defense Headquarters, Lang’ata or Kahawa army barracks to be dealt with physically without medical attention.
Airmen were never told why they had been arrested and were stripped naked, tortured to the extent of causing excessive bleeding. They were then transported to Kamiti Maximum Prison, without clothes or identification papers.
The aftermath of 1982 coup d’ etat
From 9:00 am the day after the coup attempt started, the Kenya Army soldiers sought out Airmen with a brief to subdue, kill, maim, arrest and torture as needed. Within a few hours many were dead through ambushes set all over the city of Nairobi and its environs. The instructions, seemed to have been to arrest all airmen, no matter where they were coming from. Anyone seen as a sympathizer was branded a collaborator and was condemned to arrest, torture and prolonged incarceration.
Those arrested were placed into Maximum security prisons and police cells with the Prisons Act and Police Act being ignored completely. Anybody reporting to Eastleigh camp became an immediate suspect and they were stripped naked, beaten and tortured. They were then sent to civilian jaila naked where it was explained interrogations would be carried out after which they would resume duty.
The next step was to remove all airmen and all forces in Kenya agreed to work together to subdue them. The prisons were opened to be used by the Kenya Army to lockup and torture all arrested airmen. No matter where an Airman reported, he was pronounced guilty and arrested immediately.
Interrogation: 1, 2 and 3
Artist impressions of the torture
- The drawing to the left shows an airman placed in a waterlogged cell and succumbs after several days because of fatigue in the knee high filthy and water.
- The drawing showing an interrogator using a mallet to subdue possibly destroy this victim’s nerve ending completely.
- The drawing showing the brutality with which the arrests were carried out, irrespective of where the airman reported to.
The interrogation sessions utilized torture such as beating, stress positions, use of extreme light, and placement in water-logged cells for days with no food or water. These interrogations by Kenya Army Officers; who were the arresting officers, were designed to replace what was expected to be a validly constituted Board of Inquiry, for such a serious issue.
Torture cells were established in Naivasha Maximum Security prison to obtain confessions to be used to convict the unsuspecting airmen, jailing them for long years resulting in them losing their places in the service. The Army devised a method of jailing all those promising young men who stood in the way of the occupying forces (a selected group in Kenya Army designated to replace the already condemned Kenya Air Force Personnel). It was not easy to obtain any convictions using the law as established. So they picked on Mutiny, instead of Coup. Then they literally forced all unsuspecting airmen, through coercion, torture, threats of instant extra-judicial execution and deception to sign a confession of culpability in the name of cooperating with the Government.
Nobody thought that a Government would operate in this way, so they confessed from desperation, fatigue and the desire to stay alive. Others signed as they were made to choose between going to jail and execution. Immediately after signing the confession, they were rushed to Lang’ata Army Barracks where the Court Martial was sitting and they were immediately sentenced without any legal counsel or advocate.
A simple mistake changed the fortunes of some, however. One man happened to see the headline of a Newspaper coverage of the Court martial where one of the airmen was jailed for 25 years. The torturers, however, had stated that this person had confessed and then gone back to duty. Many held in detention then refused to sign the confession opting to die rather than go to jail for many years. This resistance grew until there was none to be taken to the Court martial.
By December 1982, it was not possible to continue and by January 1083, airmen were being released from detentions in Prisons and being dismissed from the Service without following due process. A good number were sent home without anything and airmen were forced to find their way to their village, irrespective of whether they had bus fare or not, whether they had clothing or not.
After life in Prisons, all those who tried to get employment found out that it was not easy, as they had been branded rebels and were thought to be unemployable. In the meantime, all those children who were alive during the coup were growing up rapidly and asking very hard questions about what was going on in their lives and families. This started wearing down the victims, to the extent of acute depression and other mental health issues.
Fatigue on the spouses was very telling, and children were lacking school fees, meals, house rents and general upkeep, as the government kept on the campaign to isolate all former airmen. It is not clear who was gaining in all the troubles these gallant men were pushed through, to remain sick and untreated to the verge of death, to see their children suffer to the verge of rebellion, without a single helping hand, forcing these men to resign to fate and PTSD took centre stage. This trauma had reached appoint of devouring the victims completely. So as the children witnessed the suffering of their parents, it was being transferred to the children who were now grown up and to their children, since nobody had any clue, thus becoming trans-generational in nature.
So they were merely made to suffer, lack, go hungry, lose their families, as the whole world was treated to high level official deception that their parents were rebels in Kenya. Seeking for justice was also extremely challenging as one of the cases filed in 1995 by 25 airmen, but were later enjoined by 260 others in 2005, took 22 years to be concluded. The conclusion of it happened on April 15th 2016.
The Issues raised included the following; The legality of the body that was tasked by the Government to replace Kenya Air Force and carry out the exercise of ostracizing all members of the Kenya Air Force, illegal imprisonment, Torture, withheld salaries, loss of employment, removal of personal property, medical claims, etc. This unfortunately, dragged on for far too long dampening any hopes of justice, until all hope went, and depression and PTSD settled in.
This article discusses Group Therapy Model in addressing the long term effects of torture as applied in resource poor setting in an emerging democracy in Sub Saharan Africa
The group therapy model was implemented by the Independent Medico Legal Unit (IMLU), working with 56 ex Kenya Air-force soldiers who were subjected to brutal torture following a botched coup attempt in 1982 in Kenya. The model engaged 9 survivors as peer counselors who worked hand -in-hand with trained trauma counsellors to support their counterparts in the Nyanza region of western Kenya.
IMLU, - one of the leading centers against torture in Africa, provides psychological rehabilitation, medical treatment and legal support to about 500 survivors and victims of torture and their families annually, through national network of 53 trauma counselors, 70 medical doctors and 100 lawyers across Kenya.
Historical torture leaves its mark, and survivors struggle to cope with the impact of torture, up to decades later. The long term psychological and social impact of torture include ongoing PTSD symptoms (flashbacks, nightmares, anxiety, and depression), substance abuse, suicidal ideation, hopelessness, family breakdown and lack of integration into society (Blanchard et al., 1997). In addition, torture leaves scars even decades later, affecting families, even communities as was evidenced working with the group of soldiers’ spouses.
As part of IMLU’s support, full medical assessments were conducted to determine the extent of the torture on the 56 ex Kenya Air-force soldiers. By the end of the 10-week group therapy, there was a 42% reduction in symptoms across all categories of physical, behavioral, PTSD, Anxiety and Depression- A clear indication that group therapy, coupled with medical, legal and social assistance played a pivotal role in the healing process for the ex-soldiers.
Key terms: PTSD, group therapy, torture, peer counselors
THE SEQUEL OF THE TORTURE, POST- 82’ COUP ATTEMPT
The Air-Force survivors of the torture following the attempted coup sought IMLU’s support in 2014, 32 years after this atrocious event. A total of 56 men were supported (the pioneer group of 9, an additional 47 in the Nyanza region) and 9 females-spouses of the first group of 9 men.
On admission to IMLU’s therapy program it was apparent that the current circumstances of , these victims such as poverty, inability to find meaningful work or sources of income, health complications, loss of property, strained family or close relationships among others, had contributed heavily to current psychological challenges, hence exacerbating existing problems for this particular group such as acute anxiety, PTSD symptoms and depression (Amris & Williams, 2007).
As part of IMLU’s support, full medical and psychological assessments were conducted to determine the extent of the torture. Given the complexity of the health and social consequences of torture of victims’ coup and due to their geriatric profile, it was difficult to define the physical long term consequences attributable to their original injuries.
The physical assault reported by these victims included being forced to walk on their knees on concrete floors for hours and whipped before being bundled into a dark overcrowded cells where they were kicked around, and bludgeoned all over their bodies with various blunt objects including gun butts. Additionally from the history of the incident, some of these ex-soldiers were submerged in dirty water for days on end while naked, without food, and water. Most of these men sustained bruises from blunt force trauma, cuts, upper respiratory illnesses visual and auditory defects and a few reported fractures.
Among the multitude of problems presented by these ex-soldiers, persistent chronic pain in the musculoskeletal system was the most frequent physical complaint. Most of the presenting complaints described regional or widespread muscle pain and joint pain especially in the knees which they attributed to being made to kneel or walk on their knees for prolonged periods or due to physical blunt force trauma to the lower limbs. Pain related to the spine and neurological complaints such as numbness and paresthesia were also common. The main disability from this chronic pain being inability to carry simple movements, sleeping disorders and generally reduced quality of life.
Headache and back pain which were linked to severe beatings were frequently reported. Most of the pain symptoms described by these soldiers could be grouped into clusters but difficult to pin into a specific diagnosis. A few of these pain symptoms could be alluded to direct injury to the musculoskeletal system, strain on the musculoskeletal system, altered central pain modulation, neuropathic pain or somatic symptoms.
From the history, it appeared that several of these soldiers had sought treatment for their chronic pain but these symptoms had been dismissed by a number of medical practitioners possibly due to the assumption that these chronic pain symptoms were the somatic manifestation of psychological disturbances. Very few of these torture survivors have had access to specialist pain management services.
A large number of these survivors of torture complained of reduced hearing or complete hearing loss which they said was a result of boxing or clapping the ears. A few of these cases demonstrated scarring of the tympanic membrane on otoscope examination. Visceral symptoms (cardiovascular, respiratory, intestinal, and urogenital complaints) were also highly reported. However while highly prevalent, these nonspecific symptoms could not be linked to the original assault and neither could the high number of visual disturbance symptoms which the ex-soldiers presented with, as was documented in the medical reports’ case files.
Scars were the most common sign of physical torture with a high number of attributable scars being documented. Other physical findings included increased tender and trigger points in postural muscles; tendonitis, tenderness and restricted range of movement in peripheral joints and the cervical and lumbar spine. However most of the muscular-skeletal and neurological examinations did not yield much in terms of specific findings that could be linked to torture. The severity, extent and repetitiveness of the original trauma was hard to categorize. A discrepancy between the much-reported subjective pain complaints and scarcity of objective findings in these elderly soldiers, combined with relative unfamiliarity with chronic pain mechanisms, led to the widespread conclusion that these symptoms existed within a psychosomatic framework. IMLU’s medical review took place 32 years later when most symptoms were being reported as a chronic sequel of this physical torture. A large group did not present with any physical evidence of torture cruel inhuman or degrading treatment however this in no way implies that this victims were not physically tortured.
Of critical importance was that most of these ex airmen felt that the importance of their psychological problems had been over emphasized with insufficient recognition of the value of medical assessment. Knowledge about chronic post-torture pain is not widespread among most medical practitioners and research in chronic post-torture pain should therefore be clinically relevant, aiming at identifying relationships between pain and a number of clinical, functional, and psychosocial factors. These cases emphasize connections between physical and psychological trauma and the importance of an interdisciplinary approach to torture treatment.
Medical and psychological support is a key component in the rehabilitation of torture survivors. This often is combined with legal and or social support. Medical assessment and treatment, counseling at both individual and group levels, are essential components of the healing process for victims of torture. This approach is anchored in IMLU’s work in supporting victims of torture as well as their families.
The power of the group can never be underestimated. In the African context for example, studies have shown that adherence to Anti-Retroviral Therapy (ART) for People Living with HIV Aids (PLWA) improved significantly for survivors who were part of a group support in comparison to those who were not part of a group support.
In Psychotherapy, since the advent of support groups such as Alcoholic Anonymous and Cocaine Anonymous, group therapy has continued to be used in hospitals and with military veterans to mention but a few. According to Irvin Yalom (2005) in his book, The Theory and Practice of Group Therapy in which he advocates for the power of the group in psychotherapy, he asserts that “There is persuasive evidence that the rate for virtually every major cause of death is significantly higher for the lonely, the single, the divorced and the widowed. Social isolation is as much a risk factor for early death as obvious physical risk factors such as smoking and obesity. The inverse is also true: social connection and integration have positive impact on the cause of serious illness such as cancer and AIDS. (Yalom 20, 2005)”.
According to Defense Centers of Excellence for Psychological Health and Traumatic Brain Injury, peer support is an intervention that leverages shared experience to foster trust, decrease stigma and create a sustainable forum for seeking help and sharing information about support resources as well as positive coping strategies. Peer support is assistance provided by a person who shares commonalities with the target population, for example, direct experience in a particular situation or event, familiarity with a particular stressor, or other shared characteristics.
Trauma is an extremely distressing experience that the mind cannot make sense of at the time and which disrupts the body’s natural equilibrium throwing the nervous system into overdrive. The experience ruptures the survivor’s sense of predictability and invulnerability. Van der Kolk (1997) observes that it is a result of exposure to an inescapably stressful event that overwhelms a person’s coping mechanism. The 82’ coup survivors had shared concerns about feeling stigmatized especially because they felt that the then regime of the day had branded all ex air force servicemen, serving at the time of the attempted coup, as rebels who wanted to overthrow the government. The intention was that once this cohort had been counselled and then trained as peer counsellors, the peer support program would facilitate opportunities for their former colleagues in the military to be supported. The peer support program could also offer educational and social support as well as provide avenues for additional help if needed.
Over the last 2 years IMLU has been providing rehabilitation in the form of group therapy to these survivors of torture. The first set of 9 survivors who sought IMLU’s aid were taken through medical and psychological counseling. When they reported to IMLU, these survivors detailed that the torture they endured devastated not only their lives, but those of their families and community and that they would benefit from the opportunity to attend therapeutic groups to aid the healing process. Upon completion of the therapy, it was apparent that there was need to support their counterparts, in their thousands, spread out in various counties. There was therefore need to think through how this support would be implemented. The peer-counselor approach was then employed, with the group of 9 ex-service men.
Working in conjunction with professional trauma counselors to roll out the program, they would offer key components of social support, credibility, experiential knowledge, trust, confidentiality and easy access-to the colleagues in various counties. Worth noting, is that some of the group members in this cohort of peer counselors were already instrumental in the attempts of assisting their former colleagues in the pursuit of justice through legal redress in courts. This is also consistent with the criteria of screening peer support counsellors for successful peer support programs as highlighted by Keller (2005) in her article Soldiers Peer Mentoring Care and Support: Bringing psychological Awareness to the Front.
In many cases, the individuals who become peer counsellors are those who already are un-officially filling this role; they are known as a person who will always listen. The formal program therefore only provides recognition for the work these individuals are already doing and would train them to enhance their natural ability to provide support. The training for the 9 peer counselors took place over a 10 week period; it was both content and skill based. The content included general information on counselling and group therapy approaches to counseling. The cohort was made aware of ethical considerations in counseling as well as other available resources that they or their colleagues could access while facilitating the peer support groups. The skills-component which for the most part was delivered experientially included topics such as effective listening as well as how to co-facilitate a group session.
The 9 men were then paired with IMLU’s trauma counsellors to deliver group counselling to the remaining survivors. Providing psychosocial support to the thousands of survivors across the country represented a unique challenge and opportunity to address rehabilitation for historical injustice as well as establishing practices when providing psychological, medical and legal support to large groups of survivors of torture and ill treatment.
A mapping of the locations with a high concentration of survivors was done across various counties, with the majority of the men being in the Nyanza region. The first sample of 47 men were screened and taken through initial individual psychological assessments, to ascertain the need for either group or individual therapy. This was also done in order to group the members in smaller therapy groups based on the key identified psychological issues.
The assessment was one developed by the Centre for Victims of Torture (CVT) and used in all of their international programs to assess the impact of torture. CVT had given permission for IMLU to utilize these assessments and they focused on 5 key areas: Physical symptoms, Behavioral functioning, Anxiety symptoms, Depression symptoms and PTSD. At the beginning of the group, 47 men underwent the assessment and were then taken through group therapy, with all the men grouped into 4 groups in the Nyanza region of Kenya. It was noted at the beginning of the groups that most men had high scores in the Depression and PTSD categories and the groups were designed to provide therapy to decrease symptoms in these categories.
These psychological symptoms can often be debilitating and many of the men reported having resorted to self-medication and other means of combating the symptoms. The men also reported having struggled with acute stress, anxiety, PTSD symptoms, and depressive symptoms. The majority of the men had not disclosed their ordeals to family members and thus, were not able to benefit from family or social support which could have offered them some relief.
They had experienced multiple traumatic experiences that included torture at the hands of their fellow military officers as well as prison wardens. They all reported that since the exposure to the traumatic events, most of major symptoms had persisted and that they had not been able to resume their previous level of functioning. The similarity in the torture environment and methods, the fact that they were all ex-military men serving in the same camps, and their age groups were the key factors in grouping them for therapy, in addition to providing an enabling environment for group support and cohesion-majority of these men had lost contact for over 30 years, save for the few who had in one way or another managed to stay in touch.
It is worth noting that an individual's reaction to emotional trauma is complex and difficult to predict. A person's age, past exposure to trauma, social support, culture, family psychiatric history and general emotional functioning are some of the variables related to individual response to trauma (McFarlane & Yehuda, 1996). Other variables include, the emotional and physical proximity to actual danger, the degree of perceived personal control, the length of exposure to the trauma, the reaction of others to the trauma, and the source of the trauma.
Friedman (1991) postulates that nearly always all PTSD treatment should include psychotherapy (group or individual) peer group participation and family therapy. He adds that models of psychotherapy that have been used to treat former military personnel with PTSD can be broadly divided into psychodynamic treatment and cognitive-behavioral treatments. Yalom D 2005 supports this by citing catharsis, altruism and instillation of hope as some of the main outcomes of group therapy. According to Van der Kolk and McFarlane (1996) a large number of trauma survivors presents with reactions of horror, helplessness and intense fear.
At commencement of group therapy, most of the members appeared uptight, lethargic, edgy and paranoid. They seemed to be in a state of psychological disempowered, disconnected and had internalized a sense of self blame. During the first month of therapy, the therapist had a sense that somehow the members were sizing him-up. In some ways, the group members’ interpersonal relating styles evidenced the indelible marks from the severe violations they had been subjected to. The group later confirmed initial thoughts that they felt very insecure and vulnerable in the first month of therapy, that they didn’t trust the therapist or the organization, they harbored doubt about Independent Medico- Legal Unit (IMLU) and value of therapy in their lives.
The most common symptoms reported by members included persistent nightmares and flash backs associated with the themes of the traumatic events (Keller, Saul, & Eisenman, 1998). Other times, the nightmare seemed illogical with inexplicable themes, debilitating fear, startled reactions, getting overly aroused by military activities and annual commemorations, anger, irritability, shame persistent sensitivity toward specific military locations, sleep disturbances and/interruptions, long spells of being dazed - derealisation and various ailments/physical conditions.
The survivors seemed trapped in a cycle that reinforced avoidance of situations and places that triggered anxiety without a way out; which is characteristic of trauma survivors (Cunningham, & Silove, 1993). One of the group members summed up his traumatic experience and the effects as “living in a dark tunnel.” Other common issues that were not verbally reported but were revealed in the course of therapy included severely damaged self-concept which was characterized by an extremely low self-esteem and a diminished sense of self-image. Owing to their experiences, the clients were defining themselves against their torture and traumatic experiences. A good number had resigned to living life a day at a time with a bleak and blank sense of the future.
Based on the torture experience of the survivors and the symptoms they were exhibiting, the goals of therapy, were to help the individual group members:
- Acknowledge the traumatic experience by retrieving traumatic memories and review them in group sessions
- Express emotions
- Learn to deal with memories and feelings
- Master trauma symptoms
- Deal with self-concept issues and interpersonal relationships
- Find hope and meaning in life
Studies suggest that the philosophical approach and personal attributes of the counsellor largely determine the nature and outcome of therapy. For this reason, the group therapist underpinned his therapeutic work on an eclectic model with a foundation on client centered approach.
Carl Rogers opines that certain characteristics are essential for effective treatment in trauma and in establishing a working alliance; he cites these as unconditional positive regard, genuineness, and accurate empathy. Research have shown that an empathic therapist style is associated with more positive long-term outcomes. CBT, Exposure and Existential based assumptions, and skills were integrated as and when deemed appropriate.
From the onset the relationship between the clients and the therapist was based on Carl Rogers’ core conditions of therapeutic relationship, namely- accurate empathic understanding, unconditional positive regard and genuineness which laid the basis for safety and trust within the group. According to the group facilitator, this enabling environment could be attributed to the clients’ “risky talking”.
The therapist’s philosophical approach proved very beneficial and useful as it was amenable to every phase of therapeutic process. The healing process constituted three stages– safety and stabilization, remembrance and mourning and reconnection. The therapist combined principles and techniques from Judith Herman’s model of healing and narrative exposure therapy to facilitate the clients acknowledging and coming to terms with their traumatic experiences and the effects in their lives.
The central component of treatment involved processing and acknowledging memories of the traumatic events. This was conducted when enough safety and a solid therapeutic alliance had been established and the clients were not in danger of being re-traumatized or over stimulated by their materials.
The group members were also empowered with knowledge and skills on the symptoms management/coping strategies and self-soothing skills. As a result, group members felt safe to recount stories of their traumatic events in a holding and supportive environment. Judith Herman postulates that recounting of the traumatic events facilitates clients to incorporate the traumatic memories into the fabric of their overall life story. She observes,
“When a victim/survivor tells the story of his or her trauma, in detail and depth, this action can transform the traumatic memory so that the survivor can then integrate the memory into his life story. What was once overwhelming, unspeakable, and unassimilated is transformed and incorporated into the life story of the survivor, thereby empowering the survivor to no longer be held captive by the trauma and to regain authorship of his/her own experience and life.”(Trauma & Recovery, 1992).
During this phase the clients were also able to work through the process of loss and grief, they engaged in rituals which facilitated acknowledging both tangible and intangible losses. Ritual and art based techniques proved to be useful since the socio-cultural perception of men (African) discourages men from becoming emotional. It was easier for them to work through loss through rituals and art work which enabled them to stay grounded and to allow themselves to feel what they felt when they felt it.
Additionally, exposure to positive, enjoyable experiences was helpful as a way of repairing the sense of having an injured/damaged self and as a way to counterbalancing a survivor’s preoccupation with the past horror. The group members observed that besides their experiences of therapy, the three experiences, namely a narrative exposure therapy session, peer training workshops and a group termination event stood out as some of the post –positive experiences in their lives.
According to the survivors, these are some of the few times in their lives they have felt valued, accepted, cared for, and esteemed as human beings. These experiences somehow elevated their sense of self and were instrumental in supporting them to reevaluate and redefine their self-concept accordingly. Van der Kolk et al (1996), observes that clients need to find experiences that provide them with feelings of mastery, success, and pleasure. Engagement in physical activities such as artistic accomplishments, and so forth can help the person feel less “contaminated” by the trauma and can help him or her to have a more positive sense of self.
It is assumed that healing from trauma or trauma resolution occurs when the client can remember the trauma, without being overwhelmed by it (Yalom, Irvin D., with Leszcz, M. 2005). The client will then be able to tell the story of the shocking event without re-experiencing it – and as such, the event becomes a historical event (i.e., an event that took place in the past) and the person no longer feels (or reacts as though) it is still happening now.
82 EX -SOLDIERS WIVES’ GROUP
Trauma not only affects the individual both physically and psychologically; it affects those around them-family members, and significant others. It became apparent during the group therapy that the members had endured painful experiences in silence, having not disclosed this to their partners, despite the fact that their absence while away in custody and even the change in their behavior once they returned, affected their family members. Of particular interest to this group was their spouses whom they felt would benefit from some kind of support whether on a group or individual level. For the 9 men as was the case with the rest of the men in the other regions, their relationships and marriages became strained and distant.
Most of the wives became their families’ bread winners; taking care of their young children in the absence of their spouses, with very little information on what befell their husbands. Consequently most of them harbored bitterness and anger towards these men, who had gone through more pain than they could bear to disclose. Counseling for their spouses was therefore embedded into the program for the ex-army men. The joint occurrence of trauma and separation has a significant impact on emotional distress and family relationships, and the support extended to families and loved ones plays a pivotal role as an anchor of emotional stabilization and healing (Aroche, J, & Marin, L, 1994).
It was therefore agreed that ethically, the 9 men were not the best placed individuals to support their spouses, with the obvious risk of developing a dual relationship. This informed the programme towards formulating a therapy group for secondary survivors under the facilitation of two female IMLU Network Counsellors. The women were then taken through ten sessions of group therapy.
The main goal that presented during the onset of the group therapy was supporting the women to vent their anger and frustrations following their loss, especially developmental losses, during their spouses’ arrests and subsequent incarceration. Catharsis was the main approach used during the group sessions and by the end of the sessions, the women had learnt how to confront and manage the negative emotions that had manifested for the 32 years. The women were empowered with the use of relaxation techniques and encouraged to embrace social support (Schauer, et al., 2011) amongst themselves as a way of enhancing healing not only to themselves but to their spouses and children.
Psycho education on how to handle both criticism, labeling and sympathy was conducted to enable the women to cope with the ripple effects of the ills their spouses had suffered, given the fact that a documentary on the 82 Group of Soldiers that was aired on one of the major Television channels in the Country. This was very vital since the documentary was received with a myriad of mixed reactions from the public and this was found to be a stressor to the affected families.
The group was terminated upon completion of the scheduled ten sessions. During termination, the women had started working towards economic sustainability. They felt that the group was extremely beneficial, with many reporting that they feel much ‘lighter’ and less burdened by the pain, and frustration of having to take charge where they felt their husbands had failed. They felt that with the therapy, it would be easier for them to talk about what transpired with their spouses, and how their lives changed, without feeling the need to place blame on each other, but rather find this an opportunity to rebuild scarred relationships with a brighter hope for the future.
The group therapy was extremely beneficial in allowing the members to talk about, many for the first time, the impact of the 1982 coup and the events that followed. The group stated that through the group therapy, IMLU helped them to ‘alleviate the overbearing trauma that had been unattended for 32 years’, and gave them a new lease of life, allowing them to begin to heal deep seated wounds. This to them, was the ‘justice’ that they had hoped for and sought for a long time: a healing from the torture and discrimination they faced and an avenue to tell their story.
By the end of the group therapy sessions, the men were taken through the same psychological assessment they did prior to the onset of the sessions, to determine the impact of the therapy and results showed that there was a 42% reduction in symptoms across all categories of Physical, Behavioral, PTSD, Anxiety and Depression. This marked improvement in the scores registered by the men demonstrates that the group therapy, coupled with legal and medical assistance played a key role in aiding the healing process for the survivors of torture.
Upon completion of the group therapy, group members reported positive outcomes: trauma healing, marked decrease in isolation, shame stigma; renegotiations of relationships with family, developing peer relationships, developing intimate wholesome relationships, social action and giving to others, integration back to the community, empowerment and release of self-blame, but ultimately, and most importantly, installation of renewed hope and a reason to live and thrive.
During the course of the therapeutic process, some important lessons emerged:
- A client can be overwhelmed, possibly re-traumatized in the process of healing when the therapy is faster than they can subjectively contain and therefore the counsellor needs to be aware and responsible for managing the intensity of exposure to traumatic materials during the therapeutic process.
- Creative therapies- art/collage, expressive writing and rituals proved to be very effective in allowing the clients to express and process their thoughts and feelings without necessarily having to verbalize the trauma. The creative therapies, also provide an environment in which survivors felt much safer to externalize their experiences.
- Rituals and routines especially prayers, beginnings and endings rounds, grief processing rituals, writing letters, burning materials or articles are very effective and efficient in expressing/externalizing the unspeakable and discharging pent-up emotions.
- Psychological and psychosocial support and care accelerates physical healing, this was evidenced on several cases. One of the group member reported that he had stopped taking pain killer and sleep inducing drugs.
- Therapy alone may not constitute exhaustive rehabilitation of all survivors-some may require psychiatric support to deal with the after effects of the traumatic incidents.
- Treatment does not take a linear path.
- It’s important to create new meaning as a resolution to existential despair as espoused in the survivor’s questions- “Why me?” or even “the existence of existential cruelty”
- During therapy it is common for clients to experience the re-emergence of unacknowledged trauma.
Thanks to Peter Kiama for his unending support in writing and editing this article, and thanks to IMLU staff in the rehabilitation department, our network counselors, lawyers and doctors for the services and support given to the ex-82 service men and their spouses.
Last but not least, the 9 peer counsellors who were very instrumental in the group therapy sessions with their colleagues and former service men in Nyanza Region.
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd Ed.). Washington, DC: Author
Amris K and Williams A C de C. Chronic pain in survivors of torture. Pain Clinical Updates, the International Association for the Study of Pain2007; XV, Issue 7
Aroche, J, & Marin, L, (1994) 'An Evaluation of a Self Help Group for Latin American Women Survivors of Torture and Trauma.' Ibid.
Best Practices Identified for Peer Support Programs, Jan 2011- Defense Centers of Excellence for Psychological Health and Traumatic Brain Injury.
Cunningham, M., & Silove, D. (1993) Principles of Treatment and Service Development for Torture and Trauma Survivors .In: International Handbook of Traumatic stress syndromes. Edited by Wilson, J.P., Raphael, B. New York. Plenum.
Dōmen, I., Ejiri, M., & Mori, S. (2012). Narrative Exposure Therapy for the treatment of Complex PTSD: An examination of the effect and adaptation. The Japanese Journal of Psychotherapy, Vol.13, No.1, 67-74.
Friedman MJ: Biological approaches to diagnosis and treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder. 1991. New York Brunner/Mazel
Handout prepared by Shanee Stepakoff, based on Herman’s book, materials provided by Bessel van der Kolk and his colleagues during the certificate training program at the Trauma Center of Boston, and chapter by van der Kolk, van der Hart, and Burbridge “Approaches to the Treatment of PTSD”, which originally appeared in S. Hobfoll & M. de Vries (Eds.), Extreme stress and communities: Impact and intervention(NATO Asi Series. Series D, Behavioral and Social Sciences, Vol 80). Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic.
Herman, Judith Lewis (1992). Trauma & Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence. New York: Basic Books
Horowitz, M. (1978). Stress response syndromes. New York: Jason Aronson.
Keller, A. S., Saul, J. M., & Eisenman, D. P. (1998). Caring for Survivors of torture in an urban, municipal hospital. Journal of Ambulatory Care management, 21, 20-29.
Keller RT. Soldier peer mentoring care and support: Bringing psychological awareness to the front. Military Medicine. 2005; 170(5): 355. Available at: http://kcl.ac.uk/kcmhr/information/publications/articles/stress_ptsd/Keller.Soldierpeermentoring.MilM edMay05.pdf. Accessed on February 9, 2010.
Linehan, M. M., Schmidt, H., Dimeff, L. A., Craft, J. C., Kanter, J., & Comtois, K. A. (1999). Dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder and drug-dependence. American Journal of Addiction, 8 (4), 279-92.
McFarlane, A. C., & Yehuda, R. (1996). Resilience, vulnerability, and the course of posttraumatic reactions. In B. A. van der Kolk, A. C. McFarlane, & L. Weisaeth (Eds.), Traumatic stress: The overwhelming experience on mind, body, and society (pp. 155-181). New York: Guilford.
McFarlane, A. C., & Yehuda, R. (1996). Resilience, vulnerability, and the course of posttraumatic reactions. In B. A. van der Kolk, A. C. McFarlane, & L. Weisaeth (Eds.), Traumatic stress: The overwhelming experience on mind, body, and society (pp. 155-181). New York: Guilford
McFarlane, A. C., & de Girolamo, G. (1996). The nature of traumatic stressors and the epidemiology of posttraumatic reactions. In B. A. van der Kolk, A. C. McFarlane, & L. Weisaeth (Eds.), Traumatic stress: The overwhelming experience on mind, body, and society (pp. 129-154). New York: Guilford.
Robjant, K. & Fazel, M. (2010). The emerging evidence for Narrative Exposure Therapy: a review. Clinical Psychology Reviews, 30(8), 1030-9
Schauer, M., Neuner, F., Elbert T. (2011). Narrative Exposure Therapy: A short Term Treatment for Traumatic Stress Disorders (2nd edition). Cambridge, MA: Hogrefe Publishing
The National Child Traumatic Stress Network www.nctsn.org
Van der Kolk, B. A., & McFarlane, A. C. (1996). The black hole of trauma. In B.A. van der Kolk, A. C. McFarlane, & L. Weisaeth (Eds.), Traumatic stress: The overwhelming experience on mind, body, and society (pp. 3-23). New York: Guilford.
Yalom, Irvin D., with Leszcz, M. (2005). The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy- 5th Ed. Basic Books, NY.
FROM HOPELESSNESS TO REVIVAL: G.N’S JOURNEY TO RENEWAL
G.N* is a 60 year old man who has three children from three different relationships. He had been working with the 82 air force until 1982 when his dreams were shattered after the attempted coup. He lost his job having been accused of participating in the attempted coup. He was imprisoned at Naivasha Maximum prison and tortured, later released and allowed to go back home.
Upon release, he worked briefly with a shoe Company in Nairobi but because he had become an alcoholic, he lost his job. He left Nairobi and went to the village. In the village, he continued to drink and this cost him his marriage. He later got actively involved in church. This is when he was introduced to IMLU. At the time of psychotherapy, he had several issues. These included physical symptoms that needed medical attention, family wrangles, anxiety, depression and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). The client’s psychological issues were triggered by the fact that he had been tortured, lost his job, could not support his family financially and his first wife had left him because he had become an alcoholic in an effort to forget his frustrations.
He disclosed that he was actively involved in community development projects, where he was a member of several boards in the community/schools and could easily access the Governor who was his neighbour and former school mate. Counselling enabled him to manage stress, identify the triggers/stressors and how to manage them. He was taught relaxation exercises which he practiced and he admitted that they were helpful in relieving the stress.
Thankfully, he had good support systems and networks one of which was being a member of poultry development project. In the process he accessed 50 chicks which he was taking care of and once they started laying eggs would be an economic asset. He had earlier on approached the Kakamega County Governor for support where he was given money to buy a new power saw which replaced the old broken. This helped him to begin felling trees for timber. Unfortunately he did not have capital for the timber business which he desired to begin, to supplement his income from the poultry project.
After assessment by an IMLU network doctor, G.N needed some medical attention too. With IMLU’s help, he was treated at Avenue hospital which boosted his self-esteem tremendously. He was actively involved in church, determined and had faith to keep pursuing his dreams of improving himself economically. Through the support he received through IMLU’s counsellor, at the time of termination of his counselling sessions, the anxiety, depression and PTSD symptoms had reduced. He was feeling much better than he did when the sessions started and was re-energized to continue living a full life.
He applied for a loan at the County in order to boost his poultry farming where the Governor gave him Kshs 10,000.00 to buy trees that he could fell for the timber business. Currently he is rearing 50 more chicks.
His is a case of renewed strength and hope in life. Before getting the support from IMLU, G.N had lost hope in life and had sadly never had an opportunity to talk about the trauma and torture he underwent many years ago. The opportunity to meet with his counsellor to process all that, has given him a new lease of life.
He is grateful and says that finally…he can live again thanks to IMLU!